top of page

Pies

Our pies are 10 inches and will yield 8 slices. All Gluten Free pies will be topped with a gluten free crumble. On-line orders require 48 hours' notice. * Please call if you need to place an order for less than a 48-hour notice* Gluten Free Disclaimer - we do not have a separate GF kitchen. While cross contamination may be small, we do not recommend anyone with Celiac Disease consume our GF pies.


Traditional Pies

Our pies are 10 inches and will yield 8 slices. On-Line ordering does require 48 hours' notice. You may call to place a pie order at 479-224-1318.



Pumpkin

Classic, creamy Pumpkin Pie in our flaky pie crust

$26

Gluten free
Pumpkin


Mincemeat

GBP's own signature blend of spices, Dark Rum, Orange Juice, and Apple Cider. Along with Granny Smith Apples, Cherries, Apricots, Cranberries, Dates and Golden Raisins.

$28

Mincemeat


Lemon Chess

A Chess Pie is a Southern pie rich in butter, sugar & eggs. They are very rich but delicious. Our Chess pies do contain a little bit of cornmeal for texture. Classic Southern Chess pie with a hint of lemon.

$28

Lemon Chess


Chocolate Chess

A Chess pie is a Southern pie rich in butter, sugar & eggs. They will contain a touch of cornmeal for texture. Our Chocolate Chess pie is soft and creamy on the inside with a crispy, crackly top

$28

Chocolate Chess


Egg Custard

A sweet and creamy pie with a hint of nutmeg.

$28

Egg Custard


Buttermilk

A soft and creamy pie that's sweet and tangy.

$28

Buttermilk


Traditional Chess

Chess Pie is a Southern pie rich in butter, sugar & eggs. They are very rich but delicious. Our Chess pies do contain a little bit of cornmeal for texture. Classic Southern Chess pie with a hint of vanilla.

$28

Traditional Chess


Apple Butter Pie

Similar in texture to a pumpkin pie but with the great flavors of apple butter. Topped with fresh whipped cream.

$28

Apple Butter Pie


Cream Pies

Our pies are 10 inches and will yield 8 slices. On-Line orders require a 48 hour notice.



Coconut Meringue

Traditional Coconut Cream pie topped with our Italian Meringue.

$30

Gluten free
Coconut Meringue


Coconut Cream

Traditional Coconut Cream Pie topped with fresh whipped cream. * This is a cold pie *

$30

Gluten free
Coconut Cream


Chocolate Meringue

Rich, dark chocolate pie with a pudding like texture topped with our Italian Meringue.

$30

Gluten free
Chocolate Meringue


Chocolate Cream Pie

Rich, dark chocolate pie with a pudding like texture topped with fresh whipped cream. * This is a cold pie *

$30

Gluten free
Chocolate Cream Pie


Lemon Meringue

A classic tangy and sweet pie topped with our Italian Meringue. ** DISCLAIMER** Due to the nature of this pie, it needs to be consumed or removed from the pie tin within 48 hours of pickup. The acid in the lemon juice can cause the pie to take on a metallic taste if left in the pie tin. *Refunds are not applicable to this pie*

$29

Gluten free
Lemon Meringue


Banana Cream Pie

Cool and creamy with fresh banana slices topped with fresh whipped cream. * This is a cold pie *

$30

Gluten free
Banana Cream Pie


Cold Pies

Our pies are 10 inches and will yield 8 slices. On-Line orders require a 48-hour notice.



Key Lime

Creamy, sweet and tangy. Served in a graham cracker crust and topped with fresh whipped cream. We squeeze our Key Limes by hand for the freshest flavor!

$28

Gluten free
Key Lime


Lemon Icebox

Creamy, sweet and tangy. Served in a Graham Cracker Crust and topped with fresh whipped cream. We squeeze our lemons by hand for the freshest flavor!

$28

Gluten free
Lemon Icebox


Peanut Butter Mousse Pie

Rich and creamy - this is a cream cheese-based pie served in a chocolate chip cookie crust.

$30

Peanut Butter Mousse Pie


Fudge Pie with Peanut Butter Mousse

Rich and brownie like pie topped with our creamy Peanut Butter Mousse.

$30

Gluten free
Fudge Pie with Peanut Butter Mousse


Ms. Debbie's Fresh Strawberry Pie

Fresh strawberries set in a strawberry gelatin and topped with fresh whipped cream. * This is a seasonal pie; strawberries are not always in season*

$30

Gluten free
Ms. Debbie's Fresh Strawberry Pie


Butterscotch Maple Pie

Rich and creamy with a hint of maple. Topped with fresh whipped cream.

$30

Gluten free
Butterscotch Maple Pie


Peanut Butter Cream

A cool and creamy peanut butter cream pie, pudding like in texture topped with fresh cream and peanut butter cups.

$30

Gluten free
Peanut Butter Cream


Specialty Pies

Our pies are 10 inches and will yield 8 slices. On-Line orders require a 48-hour notice.



Gooey Butter

Our take on the St. Louis classic - this pie is set in our flaky pie crust, then has a layer of yellow cake topped with gooey, tangy, and sweet cream cheese.

$28

Gooey Butter


Ban-Berry Pie

Banana cream topped with a strawberry glaze then topped with fresh whipped cream.

$30

Gluten free


Cookie Dough Pie

Rich and decadent edible cookie dough served in our flaky pie crust. Topped with fresh whipped cream and our homemade chocolate chip cookies.

$32

Cookie Dough Pie


S'mores Pie

Our fudge pie topped with toasted meringue, graham crackers and toasted marshmallows.

$30

Gluten free
S'mores Pie


Tollhouse Pie

A cookie like pie loaded with chocolate chips.

$28

Tollhouse Pie


Salted Honey

An amazingly rich and decadent pie with a firm custard texture. We suggest serving cold, but not required to be refrigerated.

$28

Salted Honey


Biscoff Cream

Biscoff Cookie Butter is used to make this cream pie. Cool and creamy with hints of cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg & ginger (just like the cookie). Topped with fresh whipped cream and Biscoff Cookies for garnish.

$30

Biscoff Cream


Nutella Caramel

Nutella and Caramel come together beautifully in this cream pie. Cool and creamy with a pudding like texture - topped with fresh whipped cream.

$30

Gluten free
Nutella Caramel


French Vanilla Cream

Cool, creamy and pudding like in texture with a big vanilla flavor (pure vanilla bean paste & extract are used). Topped with fresh whipped cream.

$30

Gluten free


Mississippi Mud

A double chocolate pie with a layer of our fudge pie filling, topped with our rich chocolate cream. Garnished with fresh whipped cream.

$30

Gluten free
Mississippi Mud


Possum Pie

Our take on the official state pie of Arkansas. Pecan crust, sweet cream cheese layer then topped off with our rich chocolate cream. Garnished with fresh whipped cream.

$32

Possum Pie


Fudge Pie

Our rich brownie like fudge pie topped with fresh whipped cream served in our flaky pie crust.

$28

Gluten free
Fudge Pie


Apple Brown Sugar Betty

Buttermilk, brown sugar, apples and our oat streusel come together in our flaky pie crust.

$28

Apple Brown Sugar Betty


Miami Vice

Our traditional coconut cream pie topped with a fresh strawberry glaze. Finished with fresh whipped cream.

$30

Gluten free


The Best of Both

Two of our best-selling pies come together - our rich chocolate cream sits atop of our classic coconut cream for the best of both worlds! Finished with fresh whipped cream.

$30

Gluten free


Nut Pies

Our pies are 10 inches and will yield 8 slices. On-Line orders require a 48-hour notice.



Pecan

Traditional pecan pie - we use light and dark Karo syrup to make this classic pie.

$28

Gluten free
Pecan


Bourbon Pecan

Our traditional Pecan pie with a splash of bourbon.

$28

Gluten free
Bourbon Pecan


Chocolate Bourbon Pecan

Chocolate, bourbon and pecans - what else do you need in this amazing pie! Please note, the bourbon flavor is very pronounced in this pie.

$28

Gluten free
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan


Chocolate Pecan Pie

This is a brownie like pie with tons of pecans!

$28

Chocolate Pecan Pie


Fruit Pies

Our pies are 10 inches and will yield 8 slices. On-Line orders require a 48-hour notice. All Gluten Free pies will be topped with GF crumble*



Dutch Apple

Our classic apple filling, topped with oat streusel then drizzled with our homemade salted caramel sauce. This is our #1 pie!

$28

Dutch Apple


Apple

A classic apple pie that's sure to please everyone.

$28

Gluten free
Apple


Cherry

We use tart cherries to make the perfect cherry pie.

Full Crust

$28


Lattice

$28

Gluten free
Cherry


Blackberry Pie

Fresh blackberries in our flaky pie crust.

Full Crust

$28


Lattice

$28

Gluten free
Blackberry Pie


Blueberry Pie

Fresh blueberries in our flaky pie crust.

Full Crust

$28


Lattice

$28

Gluten free
Blueberry Pie


Peach Pie

A classic peach pie made with our special peach spice blend and served in our flaky pie crust. *seasonal*

Full Crust

$28


Lattice

$28

Gluten free
Peach Pie


Gooseberry Pie

What is a gooseberry? A gooseberry is a small tart fruit, similar in taste to a currant. This is a sweet & sour pie and worth a try.

$30

Gluten free
Gooseberry Pie


Strawberry Rhubarb

Sweet strawberries and tangy rhubarb served in our flaky pie crust.

$28

Gluten free
Strawberry Rhubarb


Rhubarb

Fresh rhubarb in our flaky pie crust.

$28

Rhubarb


Strawberry

Baked fresh strawberries served in our flaky pie crust.

$28

Gluten free
Strawberry


Raisin

Classic Raisin pie served in our flaky pie crust.

$28

Raisin


Mixed Berry

Blackberries, Strawberries, Blueberries & Raspberries makeup this delicious pie.

Full Crust

$28


Lattice

$28

Gluten free
Mixed Berry


The Blue-Goose

Gooseberries and Blueberries come together in this amazing combination. Served in our handmade flaky pie crust. This is a must try that will become a favorite.

Full Crust

$30


Lattice

$30


Crumble

$32

Gluten free
The Blue-Goose


The Half & Half

Can't decide? Then this pie is for you!! Choose from any two of our fabulous fruit fillings, and we'll do the rest. Only offered with a full crust or crumble. *GF can only be topped with our GF Crumble.

$30

Gluten free


Caramelized Pear

Fresh pears with our signature apple spice blend, topped with our sweet crumble.

$28

Gluten free


Cheesecake

Our cheesecakes are served in our 10-inch pie crust and yield 8 slices. On-Line orders require a 48-hour notice.



Brownie Cheesecake Pie

Cheesecake batter loaded with our homemade dark chocolate brownies and topped with fresh whipped cream. Served in our flaky pie shell.

$30

Brownie Cheesecake Pie


Snickers Cheesecake Pie

Cheesecake batter loaded with snickers pieces and topped with fresh whipped cream. Served in our flaky pie shell.

$30

 Snickers Cheesecake Pie


Cheesecake Pie

Traditional Cheesecake batter served in our flaky pie crust. Add fruit to the batter! Please note, we do not offer fruit topping. Any fruit will only be added to the batter before baking.

$30

Gluten free


Oreo Cheesecake Pie

Our traditional cheesecake batter loaded with Oreo cookies, set in our flaky pie crust. Topped with fresh whipped cream and garnished with Oreo cookies.

$30

Oreo Cheesecake Pie


Quiche

Our Quiche are 10 inches and yield 8 slices. On-Line orders require a 48-hour notice.



Quiche Lorraine

Hickory smoked bacon, sautéed onions and swiss cheese.

$26

Gluten free
Quiche Lorraine


Quiche Florentine

Spinach, pit ham, parmesan and swiss.

$26

Gluten free
Quiche Florentine


Quiche with Roasted Vegetables

Broccoli, mushrooms, red peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese.

$26

Gluten free
Vegetarian
Quiche with Roasted Vegetables


Quiche Forestier

Wild mushroom blend, spinach and asiago cheese.

$26

Gluten free
Quiche Forestier


Meat Lovers Quiche

Breakfast sausage, hickory smoked bacon, pit ham and ricotta cheese.

$26

Gluten free


3 Cheese Quiche

Aged cheddar, mozzarella and feta cheese.

$26

Gluten free
Vegetarian
3 Cheese Quiche


Bacon, Pimento & Roasted Poblano Quiche

Hickory smoked bacon, pimento cheese and roasted poblanos.

$26

Gluten free
Bacon, Pimento & Roasted Poblano Quiche


Bacon, Cheddar & Hashbrown Quiche

Hickory smoked bacon, cheddar and hashbrowns come together to make this delicious quiche.

$26

Gluten free
Bacon, Cheddar & Hashbrown Quiche


Sweet Potato, Spinach and Feta Quiche

Roasted sweet potatoes, fresh spinach and feta cheese come together in this quiche.

$26

Gluten free
Vegetarian
Sweet Potato, Spinach and Feta Quiche


Build your own quiche

Create your own quiche by selection from the options below.

$30

Gluten free

© 2023 by The Cafe. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page