We offer 10 inch pies or 5 inch mini pies 

Mini Pies are in-store items only - we are unable to take pre-orders on Mini Pies.  We always have 30 or more varieties in store. 

Mini 5 inch pies are $8 each or we offer a Sampler Pack of 4 for $28 

We will do our best to accommodate same day pie orders.  However, we do kindly request 24 hours notice.   * Same day pie orders will incur a 20% gratuity*

Don't see what your looking for - call us and we are happy to make it!  We can also accommodate  Vegan & Gluten Free.

We always have some of the above pies available in our daily display to take home.  If you would like a specific pie please call to order . 

Traditional Pies

Pumpkin $22

Mincemeat $24

Lemon Chess $25 - add blueberries $1

Chocolate Chess $25

Sweet Potato Pie $23

Egg Custard $24

Coconut Cream w/ Meringue $25*

Chocolate Meringue $25

Lemon Meringue $25

Buttermilk $24

Cold Pies

Key Lime $24

Lemon Icebox $24

Peanut Butter $24

German Chocolate Pie $26

Fudge Pie w/Peanut Butter Mousse $26

Fresh Strawberry w/ Whipped Cream $26

Banana Cream w/ Whipped Cream* $26

 

Specialty Pies

Gooey Butter $22

Tiramisu Pie $28

Ban-Berry $28 (Banana Cream w/ strawberry glaze - topped with whipped cream)

Raspberry Chiffon $26

Cookie Dough Pie $28

S'mores $26 ( fudge pie with toasted meringue , graham crackers & chocolate)

Chocolate Pie w/ Whipped Cream $26

Coconut Cream w/ Whipped Cream $26

 

We offer sugar-free options or no-sugar added!  The * denotes those options

Fruit Pies

Dutch Apple with Salted Caramel $25

Caramelized Pear * seasonal $25

Cherry* $24

Traditional Apple* $24 - Lattice or Full Crust

Blackberry* $25

Blueberry* $25

Peach $25

Gooseberry* $25

Ozark Mountain Grape $26

Strawberry Rhubarb $25

Strawberry $25

Rhubarb $25

Raisin $24

Grapefruit  Meringue $26

 

Nut Pies

Pecan $24

Bourbon Pecan $26

Chocolate Pecan $25

Maple Walnut $24

© 2023 by The Cafe. Proudly created with Wix.com