We offer sugar-free options or no-sugar added!  The * denotes those options

Mini 5 inch pies are $8 each or we offer a Sampler Pack of 4 for $28 

Mini Pies are in-store items only - we are unable to take pre-orders on Mini Pies

Don't see what your looking for - call us and we are happy to make it!  We can also accommodate Vegetarian or Vegan.

We always have some of the above pies available in our daily display to take home.  If you would like a specific pie please call to order . 

We will do our best to accommodate same day pie orders.  However, we do kindly request 24 hours notice. 

Traditional Pies

Pumpkin $22

Mincemeat $23

Lemon Chess $24 - add blueberries $1

Chocolate Chess $24

Sweet Potato Pie $22

Egg Custard $23

Coconut Cream w/ Meringue $25*

Chocolate Meringue $25

Lemon Meringue $25

Buttermilk $23

Cold Pies

Key Lime $23

Lemon Icebox $23

Peanut Butter $22

German Chocolate Pie $24

Fudge Pie w/Peanut Butter Mousse $25

Fresh Strawberry w/ Whipped Cream $26

Banana Cream w/ Whipped Cream* $26

 

Specialty Pies

Gooey Butter $22

Tiramisu Pie $26

Ban-Berry $27 (Banana Cream w/ strawberry glaze - topped with whipped cream)

Raspberry Chiffon $26

Cookie Dough Pie $26

S'mores $25 ( fudge pie with toasted meringue , graham crackers & chocolate)

Chocolate Pie w/ Whipped Cream $26

Coconut Cream w/ Whipped Cream $26

 

Fruit Pies

Dutch Apple with Salted Caramel $24

Caramelized Pear * seasonal $24

Cherry* $23

Traditional Apple* $23 - Lattice or Full Crust

Blackberry* $24

Blueberry* $24

Peach $24

Gooseberry* $24

Ozark Mountain Grape $26

Strawberry Rhubarb $24

Strawberry $24

Rhubarb $24

Raisin $23

Grapefruit  Meringue $25

 

Nut Pies

Pecan $23

Bourbon Pecan $25

Chocolate Pecan $24

Maple Walnut $23

© 2023 by The Cafe. Proudly created with Wix.com